Thursday, November 03, 2005

How should one blog?

Sometime ago, I watched this Channel U talkshow on TV. On that particular day, they discussed about blogs, blogging and of course bloggers.

A lawyer, a secondary school teacher and two bloggers were invited as guest speakers on the show. One of the blogger works in the media industry, while the other one is probably Singapore's most well-known (notice I did not say most popular) female blogger "Xiaxue".

One of the issues discussed during the show was: Should bloggers write in proper English?

The teacher told Xiaxue that many of his students read her blog, and that he noticed her blog was often written in broken, colloquial English, and frequently contained foul language. Moreover, she was not abashed in discussing sensitive, sensual and sexual issues. He then asked her if she could start writing in better English and on other topics so as not to allow the teenagers who frequent her blog to be led “astray”.

Her reply was: “If you think that my blog is not suitable for your students, you should teach your students not to read my blog, and not to ask me to change my writing style.”

She has a point. But, I beg to differ.

Yes, I agree that a blogger has the right to write in either proper English or broken English. He is also free to write about his own life, his thoughts or other issues as long as they are not offensive to others.

But, why write in broken English when you know proper English? Why discuss about measuring the size of penises if you have more intellectual and meaningful thoughts to share?

I feel that blogging serves the same purpose as the mass media.

The role of the mass media is to inform, educate and entertain.

Journalists write columns which are published in the newspapers. Similarly, bloggers write entries which are posted on the internet.

There must be a certain message that the journalist wants to send across to the general public when he writes. Likewise, the blogger has to have something that he wants to tell his virtual readers. That is, of course, if we are talking about responsible bloggers.

Xiaxue explained during the show why she wrote about sexual topics and why she blogged in broken English. Her reason was short and obvious, “Because that is what people like to read.” She pointed out that there are so many blogs out there which uses proper English and talks about meaningful stuff. But, the thing is, nobody reads them.

I do not mean that bloggers have to preach and blog about dull issues. But I feel that bloggers need not be swayed and manipulated by their virtual readers. Especially those bloggers who have made it big. For them, all the more they should have integrity, social responsibility and uphold a sense of morality in what they write, because what they write may have an influence on somebody else’s, or even many other people’s life.

My friend commented that this set of thinking does not apply to Xiaxue, because she started off writing in that way, and became famous because of the type of things she writes and her writing style.

Nevertheless, I feel that once a blogger has successfully attained the aim of reaching out to the masses, it is time to move on to a higher level. To improve and not degrade.

There is nothing wrong to discuss about sensual or sexual issues, but surely nobody would not like to be remembered as the blogger who takes pleasure in discussing about the size of penises?

4 Comments:

At 11:32 AM , Blogger Ellipsis said...

this area is really pretty grey, but very intriguing. let's take XX for example, i think noone has a right to ask XX to write in better english or to use less profanities, but for her own sake and with the knowledge that young minds are more sussceptible to suggestion, she should really refrain from "encouraging" them indirectly with her sometimes warped viewpoints on life. that is what we would call, social responsibility.

but then again, that also depends on her ability to discern that the opinions she places on her blog are of the occasionally-unacceptable variety. but most often, one gets the feeling that this sort of understanding might be lacking.

But then again, bloggers are really accidental mass media rather than widely accepted voices of reason, so who is to say she is wrong?

Tricky, tricky.

At the end of the day, I'm inclined to place most of the responsibility on the readers' end rather than the blogger. In a somewhat naive blogosphere (context), a blogger like XX might have to think about her obligations to society, that is the sensible thing to do. but then, none of us can say that she is entirely in the wrong as well because she might very well be, like what she always claims, just being herself. And that is not really a bad thing.

What do you think?

 
At 2:25 PM , Blogger yvonne said...

Well said.

Of course, it is up to the individual blogger how he wants to write.

I remembered XX saying that even if she did not write the things she wrote, somebody else will write them. And people will flock over to those other blogs. So even if she does not do it (write about things that may have a negative influence on youngsters), somebody else will do it anyway.

But, what I feel is, a blogger can do good with the fame that he has gained.

 
At 2:21 AM , Blogger Kevin said...

is this a freudian slip indicator of your personal views? or jus plain typo ;p

"There is ANYTHING wrong to discuss about sensual or sexual issues, but surely nobody would not like to be remembered as the blogger who takes pleasure in discussing about the size of penises?"

i think for this issue i have to say again if the whole world tot the same way then its Eden already....

i used to think that there is supposed to be a universal moral code or a guiding principle to be human. and maybe AIDs is nature's way of reminding us that some behaviour not encouraged and denial will end up in ur genes being removed from the gene pool.

then i learnt more about evolution! lol yeash....
the whole irritating thing about human's suvivability is our species' variability. there will always be one joker who wants to drive his car in the opposite direction and there's no stopping him.
the whole idea is that the species as a whole will survive better i guess..
but this is really irritating when trying to build an ethopian society...
and humans maybe frown on promiscuous sexual conduct becos they learnt the hard way that STDs kill (point in case some silly emperor who was suspected of getting std and died but they covered it up and said its smallpox?)
in the west now, finally after the shock of AIDS they are starting to want to value virginity more.. (look at eduprogs in us)

oh another thing.. you can't really argue against the point that too much sex talk can desensitize ppl or even push ppl to the other side of the fence. xiaxue has alot of haters as well! and I am sure after reading her blog they are reaffirmed of their own moral values..
so...
haha
in summary..
I dunno.. ;p

 
At 1:33 PM , Blogger yvonne said...

haha, that's a typo..I have amended it! thanks for pointing it out!

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home